{
  "scope": "Skill combat chain audit ledger for merc-fju-3.0. This ledger tracks pilot findings before wider runtime rebalance.",
  "last_updated": "2026-03-17",
  "runtime_source_of_truth": [
    "skill/*.ski",
    "skill/skill.lst",
    "src/merc.h",
    "data/symbol.def",
    "area/*/mob/*.mob",
    "area/*/obj/*.obj",
    "area/*/res/*.res",
    "src/merc.sample.ini",
    "src/merc.ini"
  ],
  "reference_priority": [
    "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json",
    "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
    "docs/3yWebsite/docs/skills.md",
    "Current runtime files under skill/, area/, src/, data/",
    "ref/ inputs for theme and naming only"
  ],
  "ref_inputs_used": [
    "ref/Readme.md"
  ],
  "ref_inputs_deferred": [
    "world-graph.json",
    "三國-MUD-世界設計總藍圖-Architecture-Map.md",
    "三國-MUD-題材分布表.md"
  ],
  "theme_basis": "Pilot batch follows existing loyang/beiping military, palace, and night-runner identity lines. New reference inputs are deferred until after the current runtime ladder is stabilized.",
  "compliance_check": "Runtime data changed in this pass for area/loyang/mob/571.mob and area/beiping/mob/9014.mob. Existing area tracker and area load order remain untouched.",
  "summary_counts": {
    "skill_files": 272,
    "skill_valid_yes": 174,
    "skill_valid_no": 98,
    "skill_enable_yes": 153,
    "skill_enable_no": 119,
    "skill_canask_yes": 148,
    "skill_canask_no": 124,
    "mob_enable_lines": 98
  },
  "global_findings": [
    {
      "key": "Attack Value",
      "finding": "Display-only combat damage number toggle in fight messages, not a damage scalar.",
      "source": [
        "src/fight.c",
        "src/ini.c"
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "Skill Value",
      "finding": "Display-only skill adeptation toggle for skill and enable listings, not an adeptation scalar.",
      "source": [
        "src/act_move.c",
        "src/enable.c",
        "src/bit.c",
        "src/ini.c"
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "Mob Practice",
      "finding": "Practice helper mob vnum used by make.c, not a direct battle strength coefficient.",
      "source": [
        "src/make.c",
        "src/db.c",
        "src/ini.c"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "legacy_reference_snapshots": [
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:cloud steps",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "english_name": "cloud steps",
        "chinese_name": "翦雲步",
        "shareable": "可以",
        "function": "閃躲類",
        "legacy_upgrade": "青玄身法(gdragon steps)"
      },
      "notes": "Used as the strongest direct old-site signal for the cloud-steps to gdragon-steps progression chain."
    },
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:hua",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "english_name": "hua",
        "chinese_name": "華山劍法",
        "shareable": "可以",
        "function": "攻擊類",
        "legacy_upgrade": "封山劍法(fonxan sword)"
      },
      "notes": "Used to explain why hua sword remains a valid old-world teacher route even when palace guards now use a different runtime ladder."
    },
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:pry",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "english_name": "pry",
        "chinese_name": "打聽技能",
        "shareable": "不可以",
        "category": "吟唱系"
      },
      "notes": "Used as a legacy player-facing classification signal only. Current repo may still expose pry through NPC teach routes."
    },
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:player-route:cloud-gdragon",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "articles": [
          "刺客精練-步法",
          "將軍精練-步法"
        ],
        "player_facing_route": "cloud steps -> gdragon steps",
        "role_signal": "common bravo/general dodge progression"
      },
      "notes": "Used to confirm that the cloud-steps to gdragon-steps chain is not just a skills.json field but an actual player-route pattern in old guides."
    },
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:player-route:starter-baseline",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "article": "新手上路",
        "starter_skills": [
          "cloud steps",
          "hua sword",
          "long fist",
          "flee"
        ]
      },
      "notes": "Used as a baseline for identifying which old skills belonged to common starter progression rather than elite guard-only ladders."
    },
    {
      "source_file": "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
      "runtime_key": "legacy:player-route:two-sword",
      "legacy_fields": {
        "articles": [
          "刺客精練-前言與說明",
          "弱弱的刺客之道 Part 2"
        ],
        "player_facing_label": "雙十 / two sword",
        "role_signal": "advanced bravo sword discussion"
      },
      "notes": "Used to show that two sword belongs to an advanced player sword route, which makes mob 559's two sword adept 1 line a role mismatch rather than merely a low number."
    }
  ],
  "legacy_area_sweep_2026_03_16_round2": {
    "scope": [
      "area/loyang/mob/*.mob",
      "area/beiping/mob/*.mob"
    ],
    "reasonable_to_keep": [
      {
        "vnum": 537,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "訓練師",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill teacher NPC. Legacy self-defense remains acceptable because its main function is training rather than frontline combat."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 538,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "醫生",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Support NPC with only a dodge line. Not a current combat rebalance priority."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 539,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "術士",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps",
          "burning hands",
          "nine steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Spell-focused civic NPC. Existing combat identity is magic-led rather than a weakened guard-family residue."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 546,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "戰馬",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Mount/animal sample; outside the current city-court-human combat ladder cleanup."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 548,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 549,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 550,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 551,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 552,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 553,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 554,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "sky shaman",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Special combat cluster, not a city or court identity sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 556,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "侍從",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Single dodge-only self-defense line; insufficient evidence that this is currently a combat weakness worth immediate change."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 572,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "郎中",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Civic support NPC with self-defense only. Low priority for combat-chain restoration."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 583,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "蔡邕",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "color steps",
          "universe"
        ],
        "reason": "Named high-tier sample with its own established legacy line, not part of the weakened city/court baseline."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 591,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "little_wind",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "linpo steps",
          "rulai"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample outside the current audit target."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 593,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "world traveller",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "ryo"
        ],
        "reason": "Named special NPC with non-civic combat identity."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 594,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "ugly dog",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "ryo"
        ],
        "reason": "Special/non-civic sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 595,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "servant",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "ryo",
          "linpo steps"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample, not a normal city service NPC."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 596,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "fly thief",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "ryo"
        ],
        "reason": "Special/non-civic sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 597,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "flower",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "ryo"
        ],
        "reason": "Special/non-civic sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 598,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "liner",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "sky blade",
          "mirage steps"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample outside the city/court cleanup lane."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 599,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "funer",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "dream soul",
          "mirage steps"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample outside the city/court cleanup lane."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 600,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "nuner",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "mirage steps"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample outside the city/court cleanup lane."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 601,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "tener",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "dream tear",
          "mirage steps"
        ],
        "reason": "High-tier special sample outside the city/court cleanup lane."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 602,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "bastard ghost",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "rulai",
          "linpo steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Boss/special sample outside the current runtime convergence target."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 603,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "evil god",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "evil king",
          "linpo steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Boss/special sample outside the current runtime convergence target."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 604,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "six demon king",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "tiger blade",
          "mirage steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Batch E fallout recheck confirms this is a high-tier地下水區 special sample. tiger blade + mirage steps remains coherent with the restored elite blade ladder and does not need civic-style adept rollback."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 9003,
        "area": "beiping",
        "role": "藥鋪伙計",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill shop-service NPC. Legacy self-defense is acceptable until a broader civic-service rebalance exists."
      }
    ],
    "fixed_this_round": [
      {
        "vnum": 571,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "流氓",
        "before": [
          "long fist 100",
          "gdragon step 100"
        ],
        "after": [
          "evil fist 60",
          "gdragon steps 55"
        ],
        "reason": "Street-thug identity fits evil fist better than a generic starter punch line, and the singular gdragon step string was confirmed to be a typo residue rather than a real alias."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 9014,
        "area": "beiping",
        "role": "錦衣侍者",
        "before": [
          "gdragon steps 100"
        ],
        "after": [
          "imperial sword 48",
          "military steps 45"
        ],
        "reason": "Sword-equipped court retainer in a guarded grain-supply node was underpowered with dodge-only legacy setup. Low-entry palace/self-defense pairing is a better runtime fit."
      }
    ],
    "suspect": [
      {
        "vnum": 512,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "地政官吏",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Civil-official identity may be overfitted to a generic fighter starter chain, but current evidence is insufficient to choose between pure self-defense downgrade and a dedicated civic-combat profile."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 570,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "詩人",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "shade steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Mixed scholar/poet flavor and unusual dodge pairing suggest a future pass, but current references do not yet justify a direct rewrite."
      }
    ]
  },
  "legacy_area_sweep_2026_03_17_batch_b_followup": {
    "scope": [
      "area/loyang/mob/512.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/572.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/537.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/538.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/539.mob",
      "area/beiping/mob/9003.mob"
    ],
    "reference_basis": [
      "plans/0003-legacy-skill-damage-audit.md Batch B",
      "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
      "docs/3yWebsite/newhand/newbies/index.html",
      "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json"
    ],
    "interpretation": [
      "Batch B re-established cloud steps as the starter dodge baseline and gdragon steps as its advanced follow-up.",
      "This made killable civic/service NPCs easier to classify: cloud steps now fits baseline self-defense, while gdragon steps reads as a higher-tier player/bravo/general dodge line."
    ],
    "reasonable_to_keep": [
      {
        "vnum": 570,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "詩人",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "shade steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Old-site holy skill docs explicitly point to the Loyang poet as the detect evil teacher, and shade steps itself is a scholar/bard-compatible dodge line rather than a pure thief-only ladder. Current evidence supports keeping this as a literary/civic flavor sample."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 537,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "訓練師",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill trainer with explicit newbie-facing service loop. Legacy self-defense remains acceptable and does not currently distort runtime combat pressure."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 538,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "醫生",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill healer with sanctuary and a doctor special. Still better treated as a service NPC than as a combat rebalance target."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 539,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "術士",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "gdragon steps",
          "burning hands",
          "nine steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Magic-led rebirth/train NPC. Its current identity is driven by spells and teaching rather than by dodge ladder fidelity alone."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 9003,
        "area": "beiping",
        "role": "藥鋪伙計",
        "legacy_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill shop service sample. Kept unchanged in this pass because runtime combat exposure remains low."
      }
    ],
    "directly_fixed": [
      {
        "vnum": 512,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "地政官吏",
        "before": [
          "long fist 100",
          "gdragon steps 100"
        ],
        "after": [
          "long fist 100",
          "cloud steps 70"
        ],
        "reason": "Civil-office NPC at the palace approach reads as baseline self-defense rather than as an advanced dodge practitioner. After Batch B, cloud steps became the clearer fit for this identity."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 572,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "郎中",
        "before": [
          "gdragon steps 100"
        ],
        "after": [
          "cloud steps 70"
        ],
        "reason": "Killable city doctor already fights through a burning hands prog. Downgrading its dodge line to cloud steps preserves self-protection without leaving a healer on the rebuilt advanced dodge ladder."
      }
    ],
    "suspect": []
  },
  "legacy_long_fist_city_service_sweep_2026_03_17": {
    "scope": [
      "area/loyang/mob/512.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/537.mob",
      "area/loyang/mob/570.mob",
      "area/beiping/mob/9003.mob"
    ],
    "excluded_non_city_or_special_clusters": [
      {
        "vnums": [
          548,
          549,
          550,
          551,
          552,
          553,
          554
        ],
        "reason": "Sky shaman cluster in special Taoist rooms 650-656. They still use long fist, but they are not city/service baseline samples for the current Batch C prep."
      }
    ],
    "reference_basis": [
      "docs/3yWebsite/newhand/newbies/index.html",
      "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
      "docs/3yWebsite/skill/holy.html",
      "area/loyang/res/loyang.res",
      "area/beiping/res/beipeing.res"
    ],
    "entry_self_defense": [
      {
        "vnum": 512,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "地政官吏",
        "current_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "cloud steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Killable civil-office NPC at the palace approach. After Batch C restored the long-fist ladder, keeping the skill name remained acceptable but adept 100 no longer fit a civil-service baseline, so the sample was retuned to long fist 70 plus cloud steps 70."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 570,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "詩人",
        "current_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "shade steps"
        ],
        "reason": "The old-site holy docs still justify this poet as the detect evil teacher and shade steps remains a literary-compatible dodge line. The fallout change was therefore not a chain rewrite but an adept rollback: keep the flavor pair, lower long fist from 100 to 70 so the restored starter ladder does not make a civic poet hit like a full combatant."
      }
    ],
    "reasonable_to_keep": [
      {
        "vnum": 537,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "訓練師",
        "current_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill trainer tied directly to newbie-facing attribute training. Long fist remains acceptable as a generic self-defense fallback, and is not the current runtime weakness."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 570,
        "area": "loyang",
        "role": "詩人",
        "current_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "shade steps"
        ],
        "reason": "Legacy holy docs explicitly anchor this poet as the detect evil teacher. Shade steps remains the right flavor line; only long fist adept needed rollback after Batch C."
      },
      {
        "vnum": 9003,
        "area": "beiping",
        "role": "藥鋪伙計",
        "current_chain": [
          "long fist",
          "gdragon steps"
        ],
        "reason": "NoKill shop service NPC with low runtime combat exposure. Kept unchanged for now; if Batch C later makes long fist too dominant, revisit together with its dodge line."
      }
    ],
    "identity_mismatch": []
  },
  "next_execution_queue": [
    {
      "target": "batch-c-fallout-recheck-complete",
      "reason": "The first fallout pass has now rechecked 512, 537, 570, and 9003. Two killable civic samples kept their identity chains but had long-fist adept rolled back; NoKill service samples remain unchanged. The next task is to watch for any further civic outliers or move to the next legacy ladder."
    },
    {
      "target": "future object gate sweep",
      "reason": "Obj 84 is now validated as a legitimate noname-gated legacy item. Only expand this queue if more RES_SKILL-gated equipment appears in later audits."
    }
  ],
  "pilot_batches": [
    {
      "id": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage",
      "areas": [
        "loyang",
        "beiping"
      ],
      "focus_skills": [
        "military blade",
        "military steps",
        "imperial sword",
        "imperial steps",
        "night blade",
        "shadowtrace steps",
        "cavalry lance"
      ],
      "focus_roles": [
        "城市守衛",
        "城門守衛",
        "騎兵",
        "禁軍護衛",
        "殿前護衛",
        "御前護衛",
        "京城大盜",
        "扶桑浪人"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "archetypes": [
    {
      "id": "city_guard_mid",
      "offensive_skill": "military blade",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        55,
        65
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        55,
        65
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "city_guard_high",
      "offensive_skill": "military blade",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        65,
        75
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        60,
        70
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cavalry_mid",
      "offensive_skill": "cavalry lance",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        60,
        70
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        50,
        60
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "palace_entry",
      "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        45,
        55
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        45,
        55
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "city_guard_entry",
      "offensive_skill": "military blade",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        40,
        45
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        40,
        45
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "palace_junior_leader",
      "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        50,
        55
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "military steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        50,
        55
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "palace_high",
      "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        75,
        85
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "imperial steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        70,
        80
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "palace_top",
      "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        90,
        95
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "imperial steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        85,
        90
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "night_runner_entry",
      "offensive_skill": "night blade",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        50,
        60
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "shadowtrace steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        55,
        60
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "night_runner_mid",
      "offensive_skill": "night blade",
      "offensive_adept_range": [
        55,
        65
      ],
      "dodge_skill": "shadowtrace steps",
      "dodge_adept_range": [
        60,
        65
      ]
    }
  ],
  "entries": [
    {
      "domain": "global_coeff",
      "runtime_key": "Attack Value",
      "source_file": "src/merc.ini",
      "current_value": 1,
      "reference_value": {
        "role": "display_gate_only",
        "expected_behavior": "show raw damage numbers in combat text"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "src/fight.c",
        "src/ini.c",
        "src/merc.sample.ini"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Keep tracked for completeness, but first-pass audit confirms it is not a combat damage scaler.",
      "pilot_batch": "global-baseline"
    },
    {
      "domain": "global_coeff",
      "runtime_key": "Skill Value",
      "source_file": "src/merc.ini",
      "current_value": 0,
      "reference_value": {
        "role": "display_gate_only",
        "expected_behavior": "hide adept percentages and 熟練度 text for mortals"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "src/act_move.c",
        "src/enable.c",
        "src/bit.c",
        "src/ini.c",
        "src/merc.sample.ini"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Keep tracked because it affects audit visibility, but it does not directly reduce NPC battle output.",
      "pilot_batch": "global-baseline"
    },
    {
      "domain": "global_coeff",
      "runtime_key": "Mob Practice",
      "source_file": "src/merc.ini",
      "current_value": 22,
      "reference_value": {
        "role": "practice_helper_vnum",
        "expected_behavior": "resolve to a valid practice helper mob"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "src/make.c",
        "src/db.c",
        "src/ini.c",
        "area/limbo/mob/22.mob"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Included because it was listed in the initial scope, but current code path shows it is not a direct balance knob for combat output.",
      "pilot_batch": "global-baseline"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:military blade",
      "source_file": "skill/m/military_blade.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_CHAR_OFFENSIVE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "NPC-only military attack skill. Valid NO is intentional so it stays out of normal player skill lookup while remaining mob-enableable.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:military steps",
      "source_file": "skill/m/military_steps.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_DODGE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "NPC-only dodge line for military archetypes.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:imperial sword",
      "source_file": "skill/i/imperial_sword.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_CHAR_OFFENSIVE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Palace-only offensive ladder. Hidden from player lookup by design.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:imperial steps",
      "source_file": "skill/i/imperial_steps.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_DODGE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Palace-only dodge ladder. Hidden from player lookup by design.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:night blade",
      "source_file": "skill/n/night_blade.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_CHAR_OFFENSIVE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Night-runner offensive ladder for thief/ronin style NPCs.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:shadowtrace steps",
      "source_file": "skill/s/shadowtrace_steps.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_DODGE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "Night-runner dodge ladder paired with night blade.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_definition",
      "runtime_key": "skill:cavalry lance",
      "source_file": "skill/c/cavalry_lance.ski",
      "current_value": {
        "valid": false,
        "enable": true,
        "teach": false,
        "canask": false,
        "type": "TAR_CHAR_OFFENSIVE"
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "npc_only": true,
        "expected_flags": {
          "valid": false,
          "enable": true,
          "teach": false,
          "canask": false
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/current-game/skills.md"
      ],
      "status": "intentional_divergence",
      "notes": "NPC-only cavalry offensive ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:501",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/501.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "military blade",
        "offensive_adept": 55,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 55
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "city_guard_mid"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Current values align with the city guard mid-band target and serve as a baseline sample.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:503",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/503.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "military blade",
        "offensive_adept": 70,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 65
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "city_guard_high"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Gate guard values already fit the intended higher guard ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:545",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/545.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "cavalry lance",
        "offensive_adept": 65,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 55
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "cavalry_mid"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Current cavalry sample already matches the intended lance-plus-military-step profile.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:565",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/565.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 82,
        "dodge_skill": "imperial steps",
        "dodge_adept": 78
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "palace_high"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "High palace guard sample matches the intended upper palace band.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:569",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/569.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 92,
        "dodge_skill": "imperial steps",
        "dodge_adept": 88
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "palace_top"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Top palace guard sample already lands in the intended elite range.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9001",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9001.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 45,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 45
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "palace_entry"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Entry palace sample is consistent with the first rung of the palace ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9002",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9002.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "military blade",
        "offensive_adept": 75,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 68
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "city_guard_high"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Current palace warrior sample fits the high military rung rather than the palace sword ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9008",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9008.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "night blade",
        "offensive_adept": 58,
        "dodge_skill": "shadowtrace steps",
        "dodge_adept": 62
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "night_runner_mid"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Night-runner mid sample already lands on the intended dodge-heavy ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9009",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9009.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 78,
        "dodge_skill": "imperial steps",
        "dodge_adept": 76
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "palace_high"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Royal guard sample already fits the intended palace high ladder.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9011",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9011.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "night blade",
        "offensive_adept": 52,
        "dodge_skill": "shadowtrace steps",
        "dodge_adept": 58
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "night_runner_entry"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Ronin sample lands in the lower night-runner bracket as intended.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:559",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/559.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "military blade",
        "offensive_adept": 55,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 55
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "city_guard_mid",
        "candidate_replacement": {
          "offensive_skill": "military blade",
          "dodge_skill": "military steps"
        }
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json",
        "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/players.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Runtime now aligns this sample to the city_guard_mid military ladder. The old gdragon/two sword mix remains documented as the resolved legacy mismatch: players.json places cloud->gdragon on a common player dodge route and two sword on an advanced bravo sword route, which justified replacing both lines for a city-guard identity.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9010",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9010.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "military blade",
        "offensive_adept": 40,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 40
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "city_guard_entry",
        "expected_behavior": "entry-level city gate guard should have a defined military offensive/dodge pair"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "area/beiping/mob/9010.mob",
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Runtime now gives this boundary gate-guard sample a defined low-entry military pair. This keeps it below the city_guard_mid samples while removing the previous no-Enable gap.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9018",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9018.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 50,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 50
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "palace_junior_leader",
        "expected_behavior": "junior imperial squad leader should have at least a low-to-mid military or palace ladder pairing"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "area/beiping/mob/9018.mob",
        "docs/current-game/skills.json",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "Runtime now gives this junior palace-leader sample an imperial-sword plus military-step pairing. This keeps it above empty entry guards but below the more formal palace guard ladder that uses stronger imperial tiers and, later, imperial steps.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:571",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/571.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "evil fist",
        "offensive_adept": 60,
        "dodge_skill": "gdragon steps",
        "dodge_adept": 55
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "street_thug_mid",
        "expected_behavior": "urban hooligan should use a thug-coded unarmed offense rather than a generic starter punch line, and the dodge skill should resolve to a real runtime key"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "area/loyang/mob/571.mob",
        "skill/e/evilfist.ski",
        "skill/g/gdragon_steps.ski",
        "plans/failenable-npc-skill-audit.md"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "This sample was directly corrected in runtime. gdragon step was confirmed to be a typo residue: the repo has only gdragon steps as a registered skill. The offensive line was also lifted from generic long fist into evil fist to better match a street-thug identity without forcing a weapon-based NPC-only chain onto an unarmed mob.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_enable",
      "runtime_key": "mob:9014",
      "source_file": "area/beiping/mob/9014.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "offensive_skill": "imperial sword",
        "offensive_adept": 48,
        "dodge_skill": "military steps",
        "dodge_adept": 45
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "archetype": "court_retainer_entry",
        "expected_behavior": "sword-equipped court retainer should have a usable low-entry sword/dodge pair rather than a dodge-only legacy setup"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "area/beiping/mob/9014.mob",
        "area/beiping/res/beipeing.res",
        "area/beiping/obj/9008.obj",
        "skill/i/imperial_sword.ski",
        "skill/m/military_steps.ski"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "This sample stands in guarded grain-supply rooms, wears a full equipment set, and wields a sword. Replacing the old dodge-only gdragon setup with a modest imperial-sword plus military-steps pair gives it a coherent court-retainer combat profile while keeping it below the palace_junior_leader rung.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_teach",
      "runtime_key": "mob:536:#Learn",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/536.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "teach_entries": [
          "hua sword",
          "flee",
          "cloud steps",
          "pry"
        ]
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "teacher_role": "escort trainer / utility mentor",
        "expected_behavior": "teach utility and entry combat support skills"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "skill/h/hua_sword.ski",
        "skill/f/flee.ski",
        "skill/c/cloud_steps.ski",
        "skill/p/pry.ski",
        "docs/3yWebsite/docs/data/skills.json"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "The teaching list is broad but internally consistent with a utility mentor role. Legacy docs explicitly support hua sword and cloud steps as old player-facing teachable lines. Pry is legacy-classified as a singing-system skill and non-shareable in old docs, so its current NPC teaching route should be treated as an intentional runtime divergence, not an automatic bug.",
      "pilot_batch": "pilot-loyang-beiping-guard-lineage"
    },
    {
      "domain": "mob_teach",
      "runtime_key": "mob:507:#Learn",
      "source_file": "area/loyang/mob/507.mob",
      "current_value": {
        "teach_entries": [
          "repair"
        ]
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "teacher_role": "smith utility mentor",
        "expected_behavior": "teach repair only"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "skill/r/repair.ski"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "This is a stable non-combat teaching route and serves as a control sample for the mob_teach domain.",
      "pilot_batch": "global-baseline"
    },
    {
      "domain": "skill_item",
      "runtime_key": "obj:84:RES_SKILL",
      "source_file": "area/limbo/obj/84.obj",
      "current_value": {
        "skill": "noname",
        "vicevalue": 92
      },
      "reference_value": {
        "expected_behavior": "RES_SKILL should point to a real runtime skill name",
        "resolved_runtime_skill": "noname",
        "linked_item_teach_path": "area/limbo/obj/215.obj -> SLOT_NONAME"
      },
      "reference_source": [
        "area/limbo/obj/84.obj",
        "area/limbo/obj/215.obj",
        "skill/n/noname.ski",
        "skill/skill.lst",
        "src/merc.h",
        "data/symbol.def",
        "docs/3yWebsite/skill/sword.html"
      ],
      "status": "ok",
      "notes": "The referenced skill name is real, fully registered in runtime, linked to an in-repo noname skill book (obj 215), and consistent with the old-site sword skill page for noname. Treat this as a validated legacy skill-gated weapon rather than a placeholder or loader-risk anomaly.",
      "pilot_batch": "global-baseline"
    }
  ]
}
